Ricardo Martín :bsdhead:

'... the only thing we both seemed to really fundamentally agree on in that discussion was "we're done". Linus'

#linux #bcachefs

OS-SCI

Breaking: Linus Torvalds drops Bcachefs support in Linux kernel 6.17 due to ongoing clashes with developer Kent Overstreet. Tensions rise over submission rules and new features during RC phase. #Linux #KernelDrama #Bcachefs dub.sh/8FcVSd1

New Linux Kernel Drama: Torvalds Drops Bcachefs Support After Clash - Slashdot

Bcachefs "pitches itself as a filesystem that 'doesn't…

linux.slashdot.org
Linuxiac

Disagreements over late-stage fixes and developer conduct led Linus Torvalds to drop Bcachefs from the upcoming Linux kernel 6.17 release.
linuxiac.com/torvalds-drops-bc

#linus #bcachefs #linux #kernel #opensource

Thorsten Leemhuis (acct. 1/4)

Look like @torvalds might remove #bcachefs from the #Linux with version 6.17:

lore.kernel.org/all/CAHk-=wi+k

'"I have pulled this, but also as per that discussion, I think we'll be parting ways in the 6.17 merge window."'

Backstory that triggered this can be found here:

lore.kernel.org/all/CAHk-=wi2a

To quote from there:

'"You seem to have forgotten what the point of the merge window was again.

We don't start adding new features just because you found other bugs.

[…]

Make the -rc fixes be pure fixes.

Linus"'

#kernel #LinuxKernel

txt.file

IMHO: If you are a file system developer and do not care about the LTS branches of the Linux kernel your file system should not be part of the official Linux project. #BCacheFS

Reference: github.com/koverstreet/bcachef

Data corruption with "Journal stuck? Waited for 10 seconds..." · Issue #900 · koverstreet/bcachefs

Hi. I think I'm not using bcachefs the way it is supposed…

GitHub
Jun 05, 2025, 19:18 · · · 2 · 0
Thorsten Leemhuis (acct. 1/4)

Highlights from the main #bcachefs merge for #Linux 6.16: git.kernel.org/torvalds/c/5225

- Incompatible features may now be enabled at runtime, via "opts/version_upgrade" in sysfs.

- Various changes to support deployable disk images

- Major error message improvements for btree node reads, data reads, and elsewhere.

- New option, 'rebalance_on_ac_only'.

- Repair/self healing:

- We can now kick off recovery passes and run them in the background if we detect errors.

- Performance:

- Faster snapshot deletion

- Faster device removal

- We're now coalescing redundant accounting updates prior to transaction commit, taking some pressure off the journal.

- Stack usage improvements: All allocator state has been moved off the stack

#kernel #LinuxKernel #Linux616 #Filesystem

Thorsten Leemhuis (acct. 1/4)

Migrating away from #bcachefs

blog.sesse.net/blog/tech/2025-

Steinar H. Gunderson aka Sesse writes:

'"[…] I've converted my last bcachefs filesystem to XFS, and I don't intend to look at it again in the near future. […]

I no longer trust bcachefs' future. […]

[…] I've had catastrophic data loss bugs that went unfixed for weeks despite multiple people reporting them. I've seen strange read performance issues. I've had oopses. […] “oh, yeah, that's a known issue […]

There are more things: […]"'

Thorsten Leemhuis (acct. 1/4)

A few bits from the main #bcachefs merge for #Linux 6.14:

git.kernel.org/torvalds/c/2622

"'Lots of scalability work, another big on-disk format change. […]

Like 6.11, this is another big and xpensive automatic/required on disk format upgrade. This is planned to be the last big on disk format upgrade before the experimental label comes off. There will be one more minor on disk format update for a few things that couldn't make this release.'"

#kernel #LinuxKernel

Thor A. Hopland

Aaaaaw crap. #BCacheFS is what I want to replace my #BTRFS partitions. But, it seems that BTRFS might actually win back performance gains quicker than BCacheFS will become mature enough to use - if it ever becomes mature enough.

At this point it's probably a safer bet to wait for ReiserFS5 lol

youtube.com/watch?v=QfyJNlMl1h
@BrodieOnLinux

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original…

www.youtube.com