While you should stop using LastPass in favor of better password manager soon, I think it's important to keep a few things in perspective:
1. This isn't your fault. LastPass fucked up. It was reasonable to trust them, and they betrayed your trust. (Infosec folks: Do not shame people for not knowing this. If we knew and they didn't, that's on us. We should have communicated this better.)
2. You are still in a way better position, having used a password manager, then you would have been if you just reused passwords or used some predictable scheme for them. This is NOT some kind of proof that password managers (even cloud password managers) are inherently a bad idea. The alternatives are worse.