In languages with grammatical gender, it has been evidenced that using masculine forms as a generic reference induces a bias favoring masculine-specific representations. It is worth repeating that this statement is a well-established scientific result, not a matter of conjecture or debate (See my previous thread here: qoto.org/@leovarnet/1104572493) (2/7)

There are two main strategies to counteract gender biases in language: neutralization (using gender-unmarked forms such as “l'enfant” in French) or re-feminization (contracted double forms such as “un·e enfant”). Here, we explored the relative efficiency of these strategies. (3/7)
@linguistics

We employed a sentence evaluation paradigm, where the participants had to decide whether a second sentence starting with a gendered personal pronoun (“il” or “elle”) was a sensible continuation of the first sentence written in a gender-fair form, either a gender-unmarked form or a contracted double form. (4/7)

The findings indicated that gender-unmarked forms do not fully neutralize the masculine bias. For example, “l'enfant” has no fixed grammatical gender, still our participants mostly interpreted it as "male child". This is probably because, in everyday language, gender-unmarked forms are often used as generic masculine terms (“Ils ont eu un enfant”) or carry underlying masculine stereotypes (e.g. "citizen" in George Bush’s “We cannot tolerate attacks on the wife of an American citizen”). (5/7)

On the other hand contracted double forms (“un·e enfant”) are more effective in promoting gender balance, as they explicitely reintroduce grammatical gender markers associated with the feminine gender. (6/7)

The publication of this article is remarkably timely, given that the French National Assembly is currently slated to examine a bill put forth by the far-right party, aimed at banning the use of "inclusive writing" (in fact mid-dots) from all administrative documents…blogs.mediapart.fr/eliane-vien (7/7) @MarCandea @laelia_ve

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.