How does confidence compare to explicit feedback in learning?
We explore this in a new pre-print!
With @andreapisauro and Marios Philiastides
@CCNiUofGlasgow

We use simultaneous EEG-fMRI to localise BOLD related to single-trial representations of confidence and explicit feedback value, and relate this to how participants learn to improve in a perceptual decision-making task.

biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/20

This is not just a party trick. We can use nested cognition to better understand metacognition. For example, we show confidence in this context must rely on a fine-grained representation of the perceptual decision-evidence, compared to discrete bins.

Show thread

Confidence was better than predicted if we assumed all the variability disrupting metacognition would be passed on to the next re-evaluation: relative performance could improve from one re-evaluation to the next.

Show thread

A toot-summary of our recent article!

We often use our confidence to gauge the reliability of our perception.

But what about the confidence... in our confidence?
Sometimes, we can be certain we are uncertain.

With Samuel Recht, Ljubica Jovanovic, and Pascal Mamassian, we had fun testing the limits of meta-metacognition in a classic visual task.

We found surprising accuracy of confidence up to the fourth order (confidence in confidence in confidence, or meta-meta-meta-cognition).

Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.