@lack New thread. This one isn’t a question of why you are an atheist - different question. Why has atheism never (really) been a thing until recent history? Surely there were philosophical and scientific geniuses in prehistoric civilization and in the ancient world - they discovered fire, invented writing, invented the wheel, discovered how to cultivate plants and domesticated beasts of burden. They did this while performing excruciating manual labor, under constant privation (by modern …
@wagesj45 1. The very point I was trying to make earlier was that the sharpest #scientific minds of the current age are absolutely pitiful compared to their 25000 BCE equivalent. Surely somebody would have “discovered” #atheism relatively early on, but belief in the paranormal and supernatural has been the norm among the #literate classes since the invention of #writing.
@wagesj45 2. the punishment for apostasy was also death in seventeenth-century #France, and twentieth century #China. Why was there never an #atheistic tribe before that time? Surely they, too, would have punished apostasy with death.
@wagesj45 Come to think of it, the very first #Christian was also punished, by death, for apostasy. That didn’t prevent #Christianity from emerging as the prevailing culture
@wagesj45 And, the fact that they didn’t believe in the same supernatural being suggests that atheism/materialism seemed equally implausible to non-overlapping civilizations separated by geography, culture and language
@b_chocolatey those are some big claims that i'm not sure i believe.
but even assuming every person believed in the same super natural being (which they don't), it feels to me like the likelier explanation is that early man was scientifically unsophisticated and tried to explain the world around him in terms he was familiar with. also its generally not a good idea to go against the tribe when you depend on them for survival, especially if "god" has decided the punishment for apostasy is death.