The results are in! Although a majority said (a), for this particular setup, (b) jumps higher.
This is NOT a general rule in biological jumpers, and is particular to how we've set up the problem (notably, no force-velocity relationship) #biomechanics
All that matters is the amount of work done by the muscle. Since there is no force-velocity relationship, the work done is proportional to the shortening distance. Case (b) wins because the larger in-lever allows the muscle to shorten more
We have an intuition that (a) should be better because biological jumpers look like that. But this is to accommodate power-velocity relationships in muscle, which this setup doesn't have.
My intuition was initially drawn to (c), but the physics clearly show (b) as the winner here. A good reminder to check model assumptions!
If anyone has a good real-world example analogous to this setup, let me know! Force-velocity is pervasive, though
Is it better to jump with a long foot or short foot?
The cases below only differ by whether the in-lever or out-lever is bigger. Which will jump higher?
Ignore contraction dynamics & imagine the body is constrained to go straight up.
Answer and discuss below 👇 #biomechanics
Thanks to all who made it to my talk at #SEB2023! For those who couldn't, here's a prerecorded version https://youtu.be/BIwkG6a5WEo
Watch to find out when it's better for a foot to be a foot vs a leg... And how #lizard toes are a bit like wheels 🦎🛞
What does this #3Dprinted device have to do with #Lizard feet? To find out, come to my #SEB2023 talk Fri at 9:30 in Tinto for the Open #Biomechanics session: "Plantigrade feet avoid work through serial linkages"
You might even get a copy to take home (while supplies last)! 🦎👣
Hoping to connect over here with #evolution #biodiversity and #biomechanics folks! Will aim to post and support others. Here is a cool surgeonfish (Ctenochaetus) we dissected recently.
For the record, I acknowledge that the wrist contacts the ground, so the forelimbs are unambiguously plantigrade. To my eyes, though, the hindlimbs are digitigrade.
Also, not everyone agrees in the literature; some authors explicitly say mice are digitigrade - e.g.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fbioe.2018.00061
Are #mice and #rats plantigrade or digitigrade?
I've seen a loooot of studies that code them as plantigrade (e.g.
https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1814329116)
... but their ankle is well above the ground (e.g. video from https://doi.org/10.3389/fnins.2016.00042)
What am I missing? 🐀 #biomechanics #mammals
"In an effort to be both environmentally and fiscally responsible, [University] will contact only candidates receiving an interview"
Didn't know automated rejection emails were so expensive and polluting 💵 #academicjobs #AcademicLife
My #SICB2023 poster and video presentation on animal #locomotion and passive dynamic #robots are up on SICB+! Head to the meeting website to check them out
https://sicb.econference.io/public/5X9OIbU/main/sessions/9874/31486
RT @sjoerdmb@twitter.com
We ar looking for 3(!!!) new colleagues at the assistant prof level! Come and be my colleague!
https://workingat.vu.nl/ad/assistant-professor-human-movement-sciences/xx4bb9
Any recommendations for #dinosaur activities for a class of 4-5 year-olds? Visiting my daughter's classroom in a few weeks to talk about #dinosaurs, but coming up short on ideas! I have access to #3dprinting and laser cutter if that helps... #SciComm #education 🦖🦕
@BryanLastRedDrop @KFuentesGeorge
"For a child accustomed to stolen possessions and broken promises, the only guaranteed treats are the ones you have already swallowed"
"Waiting is only the rational choice if you believe that a second marshmallow is likely to actually appear after a reasonably short delay—and that the marshmallow currently in your possession is not at risk of being taken away"
Unreliable adult? Kids wait 3 mins.
Reliable adult? Kids wait 12 mins.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0010027712001849
Demos nearly ready for my poster presentation at #SICB2023 ! Come to P2-227 tomorrow (Thursday) 430-530 PM to play with these #ComparativeBiomechanics #dynamics #biorobotics
RT @BatConIntl
Can you see the bat sleeping in the snow?❄️
The Ussuri tube-nosed bat (𝘔𝘶𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘢 𝘶𝘴𝘴𝘶𝘳𝘪𝘦𝘯𝘴𝘪𝘴), found in Japan, Siberia, & Korea, is one of only two animals known to hibernate in snow- the other being polar bears.
https://www.batcon.org/snuggling-up-for-winter/
📷Yushi & Keiko Osawa
Another #introduction post for all the new Twitter people (and just new people in general!). A little about me: I’m Sabrina - I’m a #writer (some #scicomm) and #author of #ScienceFiction (and #ClimateFiction and #dystopian) #books - my series Aestus was on the Amazon hard #scifi bestseller list recently. 😊 I also do #archery and #photography and enjoy #hiking - I would love to get into #astrophotography. I am learning #German and really enjoy good convos/coffee/tea. Sry for so many hashtags 😅
Just seen on Mastodon that the Sony/BMG royalty dispute means Rick Astley's "Never Gonna Give You up" is now blocked globally on YouTube. Playing just yields a "blocked in your region" message.
Absolute end of an internet era. 😔
Postdoc at Structure and Motion Lab, Royal Veterinary College. Biomechanics, animals, robots. Husband and Father of four. Opinions my own. (He/Him) http://dtpolet.com