@redbassett @johncarlosbaez @jsdodge @wtgowers @pluralistic I still hold out hope that it may become truly decentralized in fact, but it seems like there's lot of confusion between the intent of the design and the current state of affairs.
That being said, what they can fairly claim now is that there are 3rd party (mostly self-hosted, I think) Personal Data Servers (PDSs) that hold all the information relevant to an account, so if you use one of those you do really have independent control of your data. By contrast, on Mastodon you need the server instance you use to remain up and cooperative to move your account to another or export your data.
I've been thinking that what would be useful would be for someone to do a sort of Failure Modes and Effects Analysis like you might do in certain fields of engineering, i.e. to contemplate the different sorts of failure modes of each service that might be likely (e,g, enshittification, organizational collapse, intrusion) and what the impact would be on users (including any path to recovery). I think that would be more salient than a lot of discussions I see that focus directly on technical aspects of architecture.
I don't really know why people study astronomy in such great detail - except that it's fun. I think it's important to understand how the universe as we know it began about 14 billion years ago, and understand how the Earth was formed about 4.5 billion years ago, and how evolution brought us here. My life fits into this frame. But is it important to know the various dramatic ways that stars can die?
I don't think so... but it's sure fun!
Here's a tiny white dwarf star called a 'polar' sucking hot gas from its much larger but lighter companion. It's called a 'polar' because its magnetic field is so strong that the gas falling in is forced to move along the field lines, rather than forming the usual pancake-shaped 'accretion disk' and slowly spiralling in.
This means the ionized gas falling onto this white dwarf lands only on its north and south magnetic poles. It's like how ions from the Sun hit our Earth near its poles, producing auroras there. But it's vastly more intense! The magnetic field of a 'polar' is about 100 million times stronger than the Earth's magnetic field. And a lot more stuff is falling in. Now and then a *huge* amount.
So, polars are considered 'cataclysmic variable stars': now and then they blast out huge amounts of radiation, as a clump of infalling gas hits their surface. There are different kinds of cataclysmic variable stars. This is just one!
Now, why is it so fun to think about this... instead of, say, politics, or ecology? I guess the question answers itself. So now I'm wondering how much we can justify science based on escapism. Maybe a bit is okay. We need to have some fun, after all.
@redbassett @johncarlosbaez @jsdodge @wtgowers @pluralistic This post goes into some detail to argue that while they do seem to be aiming at decentralization, as of today key parts of the Bluesky infrastructure are not effectively decentralized.
@trobador @johncarlosbaez @jsdodge @wtgowers @pluralistic It looks like there may additionally be some troubling connections (including to Russian state media) with their series A funders. That in addition to the basic structural dynamics of corporations and venture funding probably constitute a reasonable basis for at least some caution.
If you were chased here from Twitter, it's just possible that you won't be aware that a lot of people are now leaving Twitter (or X if you must) for BlueSky. I mention this because I personally very much valued having a thriving maths community on Twitter while still being part of the wider world, so to speak. My experience here, which may be as much my fault as Mastodon's, is that there are lots of interesting people but not quite the atmosphere that I liked on Twitter. It would be a bit cheeky of me to suggest deserting Mastodon, but perhaps you might like to consider trying out BlueSky -- I would be very happy if we could use it to recover what Musk stole from us.
What does the income look like for a local newspaper?
The Halifax Examiner, a truly superb daily (@philmoscovitch writes for it) posted its tax return online here: https://www.halifaxexaminer.ca/morning-file/heres-the-halifax-examiners-tax-return-2/
... along with a summary
Nearly all the money comes from subscribers
It's a tight, tight ship!
(I subscribe myself, because the online daily blog is *amazing*)
The lesson for us all: If you have the money free, subscribe to support your smaller, truly local media
we're the only ones keeping it going
@james Given that Mastodon was viewed as the primary Twitter alternative back in 2022 when people first started fleeing Elon, this should spur some serious reflection within the Mastodon community. Mostly I've seen discussion that takes the form of blaming the users (which doesn't seem likely to improve the situation).
While the number of scientific papers continues to grow exponentially, our knowledge of the world is only growing linearly.
According to this study: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.08349
Mozilla has a survey open to the public about their future, and thoughts on tech. Who knows if responses will actually matter, but maybe add your own thoughts to balance out the inevitable flood of crypto and tech bros?
Remember, they just fired a giant chunk of their advocacy team, and they are abandoning the #fediverse. Their CEO's salary is $7MM. It was just over $2MM in 2018. Has Mozilla's value to you tripled in 6 years? Has YOUR salary tripled in that same time frame?
#Mozilla @mozilla https://mozillafoundation.tfaforms.net/101
@mshiltonj See for example this discussion:
https://hachyderm.io/@mekkaokereke/112860037633719411
Mastodon, it's really simple.
You want everyone to leave the dodgy car salesman's X-hole?
You want a future where social media is community-owned and decentralised, instead of a corporate surveillance sphere?
Well, those things won't happen until Black Twitter migrates here.
And Black Twitter won't touch this place until there's proper moderation in place.
The issues raised by Mekka, Timnit, Kim, Sam, and others are not a peripheral issue.
Fixing moderation is absolutely central, core work that is mission critical for the Fedi being successful.
And if you don't do it, then please don't complain when (not if) everyone leaves for BlueSky.
EDIT: In terms of the kind of moderation tools that are needed, take a look at this post by Mekka: https://hachyderm.io/@mekkaokereke/112860109548583248
Childhood mortality -- death before age 15 or so -- used to run at about 50%.
Every second child born, died before becoming an adult, all over the world, for as far back as we've been able to track.
We didn't turn the corner until about 1900, when science got us the germ theory. That sparked sanitation and vaccination.
A cabinet nominee (RFK Jr) who questions vaccines is frightening. A nominee who brags about not washing his hands (Hegseth) is terrifying.
@doener Nice article! It did a good job of being just detailed enough about the Bluesky architecture to be informative but approachable. It was also a nice balance of expressing options without unwarranted certainty.
You talked about wanting to see posts from people you follow without reposts. I did want to mention the OnlyPosts feed, which may not be exactly what you want but is in the ballpark.
As far as the decentralization/federation, it sounds like PDSs are pretty easy to self-host, and most of the other stuff could be self-hosted, except maybe the AppView and the DMs. Is that right?
"When writing about #Bluesky, I’ve seen folks mention that it’s either federated or decentralized. I’m here to tell you that it’s currently neither."
Half-Life 2 is currently free on Steam. They've added a big update to celebrate its 20th Anniversary with lots of bug fixes and new commentaries. ![]()
https://store.steampowered.com/app/220/HalfLife_2/
https://www.half-life.com/en/halflife2/20th
The Orange Box is also currently on sale for 90% off ($1.99)
#GrapheneOS doesn't come with text-to-speech enabled or set up by default.
https://github.com/espeak-ng/espeak-ng is not compatible with the current Android versions and https://github.com/RHVoice/RHVoice doesn't have support for #German.
Any recommendation for me? FOSS preferred. 🤔
@michael How does this compare to what is provided by bridgy?
https://fed.brid.gy/
Moved to Mathstodon.xyz
Theoretical physicist by training (PhD in quantum open systems/quantum information), University lecturer for a bit, and currently paying the bills as an engineer working in optical communication (implementation) and quantum communication (concepts), though still pursuing a little science on the side. I'm interested in physics and math, of course, but I enjoy learning about really any area of science, philosophy, and many other academic areas as well. My biggest other interest is hiking and generally being out in nature.