A particularly draconian form of censorship is coming. Prior restraint bans content before publication and before a court has decided that it's illegal.
The #OnlineSafetyBill is a dangerous threat to free speech. #censorship #freespeech #ukpolitics
Read more from ORG Policy Manager, Dr Monica Horten: https://www.openrightsgroup.org/blog/small-boats-and-silent-protest-prior-restraint-in-the-online-safety-bill/
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/04/stop-csam-act-would-put-security-and-free-speech-risk
With the other, rather than simply holding someone liable for deliberately hosting child abuse photos, it creates a censorship board which can go around taking down content they don't like (no judicial decisions required).
Such a board would be very susceptible to abuse and over-reach.
This bill would also make services (who might be very small) vulnerable to legal harassment from bad actors (such as certain religiously motivated American ones).
Given that services don't really want this kind of content on their services, it's not clear whether they'd moderate better with other provisions of this bill, or whether they'd do whatever they can to "do something" (even if that something is harmful).
The first one, EARN IT, has made appearances before. It threatens to undermine privacy by making internet service providers search through private messages (including in encrypted messages, effectively banning E2EE) for illegal content.
It is also a threat to freedom of expression and people's trust in services.
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/05/eff-letter-congress-oppose-earn-it-act-and-stop-csam-act Oppose these two bills. They violate the First and Fourth Amendments, as well as other parts of the Constitution.
https://edri.org/our-work/eu-plans-allow-big-tech-to-exploit-your-medical-records-without-permission/ E.U. plans to mandate health providers to share health records with a "government agency" who will share it out to random researchers (including tech firms and without a patient's consent).
From an ethical perspective, this is terrifying. This is information which a patient entrusts in confidence that it won't end up in some strange place, whether with a researcher, a tech firm, or a criminal (a centralized store could be breached).
https://chatcontrol.wtf Oppose the fascist E.U. spying / censorship bill. It won't stop (probably already isn't stopping) just at real abuse / exploitation.
Software Engineer. Psy / Tech / Sex Science Enthusiast. Controversial?
Free Expression. Human rights / Civil Liberties. Anime. Liberal.