Wanted: a visual debugger for academic texts

@bthall @freemo e.g.: you're using xy method but your input is ab. i think what you're actually trying to do is smooth out your graph so your hypothesis looks correct.

@meena @freemo Could you please explain that last sentence some more? I'm not following how it relates to those before it [my limited programming knowledge might be why] 😥

@bthall @freemo and i'm not a statistics person 😅 so i hope i didn't go too much overboard here…

often someone will use a very very specific statistical method even tho that's not something you'd usually use for such a use-case. e.g.: it doesn't fit the "input" (number of people analysed / number of people of actually matching) so that the results you've found will still somehow fit your initial hypothesis.

hope that makes it more clearer.

@meena @freemo ooh! I understand what you said now! 😗 I think that the debugger alone might not be sufficient for catching this error, but if a Theory Graph could be developed and integrated with the debugger, the debugger could catch this wrror.

Follow

@bthall @meena We are basically talking about a formal logic checker?

@freemo @meena Yes, but especially in a way that allows for effectively parsing and appraising a work

@meena It isn't that PDF is the wrong solution to the problem, it's that it's a bad solution to the problem, a very, very bad solution with many better, alternative solutions.

@bthall as one of the people in the thread mentions, pdf has rich metadata. unfortunately many people (or tools) don't use it

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.