@muehlfield@social.tchncs.de Could be, in theory. In practice that doesnt seem to be the case.

Ask yourself this, how many people in poverty or on the edge of poverty picked a career path specifically because of it being well paid and spend every or most night studying in books or practicing said trade in their free time? Of the people I know literally not one of them.

Likewise, of the people you know who did pick a profitable career patha nd study and invest in that skill set every day for years and havent given up on that dream, how many of those are living well above the poverty line? From what I've seen nearly all of them.

I am a successful person financially, I try my best to use what I learned to achieve that success to help others on a similar path. In almost every case the above has held true, Ic ould tell you in the first weeks of taking someone under my wing, based on their own dedication and choices, who is going to be successful and who will be stuck in poverty. Here we are decades later and nearly every one of those predictions seem to have come true. I realize this is anecdotal but to me it seems a pretty obvious truth from my own experiences taking people in and trying to help them towards success.

With that said the system is absolutely not flawless. The big issue is that many people in poverty or born to poverty (not middle class, poverty) are at an unfair disadvantage. They were raised by parents in poverty and parent who never learned how not to be in poverty. They never had the knowledge needed to teach their kids how to succeed. that is unfair and the system should try to compensate for that, no doubt. But what that means is yes, anyone can succeed, but most people simply arent given the life lessons one would need to be able to. The System should provide better help to correct for that.