@Science

**Interesting fact of the day**: The speed of light has only been proven to be a constant speed **round trip**. Not the instantaneous speed of light nor the speed of light while heading in a single direction has ever been able to be proven as constant.

In other words, it has never been experimentally disproved that light doesn't, for example, preferentially travel at half the speed of light in one orientation, but instantaneous in another. In fact it may very well be impossible to test the one-way speed of light due to the very consequences of relativity itself.

@freemo @Science This is not correct according to my understanding of physics. Specifically addressing the claim that it is not testable: you could have distance separated sensors send light to each other and see how long it takes. If it takes longer in one direction than the other than the theory that the speed of light is constant would be falsified. Maybe I'm not understanding something, but I believe your claim is false. If I am missing something I'd love to know what.

@seroom

Yes you are misunderstanding the fundemental problem.. if you do this experiment as you propose it would require both sensors to have synchronized clocks with very high accuracy correct? Synchronizing the clocks would be impossible if the speed of light is asymmetrical without knowing what that asymmetry is ahead of time. Worse yet, the error in synchronizing those clocks due to the asymmetry would be exactly enough to cause the experiment to incorrectly show that the speed of light is the same in both directions.

Ergo, your experiment would not be able to detect asymmetry in the speed of light if it existed.

@Science

@freemo There are ways of synchronizing clocks and doing the experiment. :) @seroom @Science

Follow

@pthenq1

No there isnt. This isnt my opinion, the scientific community agrees that so far no one has figured out any way to measure the one-way speed of light. If you have an experiment that can you'd get a nobel prize for it.

@seroom @Science

@freemo A scientist could read this and could let you know his thoughts... But he is polite-- do not get offended :P

@seroom @Science

@pthenq1

I'm not offended, just saying the fact that light has only ever been measured two way is well established fact.

@seroom @Science

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.