While GPT/AI/ML chatbots are all the rage, might I remind an older fact-check I wrote about whether or not GPT-3 is "conscious":
tecc.media/claim-gpt3-is-consc

> Ascribing any meaningful form of subjective experience or awareness to GPT-3 remains a stretch, to say the least.

>Saying that GPT-3 is conscious because it can generate text that looks like it is human-written, is like saying a large screen TV is a window because it can show images of the great outdoors.

@rysiek I heard from @ahrimana that their proffesor told them rhat the right question is "can it suffer"

@meka @ahrimana hah, not bad.

For me the right question is: who owns these models, what data were they trained on, and what are they being used for?..

I am very aware that this kind of tech can and is used for Mathwashing:
mathwashing.com/

Follow

@rysiek @meka @ahrimana

Do you mean complex models in general, or generative text models in particular? If latter, then I don't see it: Could you describe how they could be used for mathwashing? (I fully expect them to be used to confuse people and automation.)

@robryk MIcrosoft GitHub Copilot is mathwashing of copyright infringement, for example.

"We totally are not copying your code! No, no, we just trained our model on it, and it *happens* to generate similar stuff. Totally different! Not infringement!"

@meka @ahrimana

@rysiek @meka @ahrimana

Huh, ok, I wouldn't have thought of this as mathwashing. <s>Damn those humans and their imprecise language.</s>

@rysiek @meka @ahrimana

Upon further reflection it's obviously mathwashing according to most definition I can think of (which are along the lines of "using misconceptions about fairness/neutrality/genericness of outputs of automated processes when no explicit bias was used in their creation").

@rysiek i do agree but my comment was about cognitive abilities. If you include digital rights, story becomes insane @ahrimana

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.