One thing that still surprises, decade+ into living here, is that Ireland goes in for giant empty roads. I ain’t complaining, but I wonder how it comes about.

@psn Do you mean that the distribution of size of roads in the middle of nowhere is shifted towards larger, or that it's bimodal, or something else?

@robryk I mean, once you get out of urban areas, the size of the n roads is considerably larger than the observed demand. Doesn’t really apply to the local roads, which are often very narrow.

Follow

@psn So it's ~uniformly larger among roads that don't appear to be local, or is it that some roads that you'd expect to be in the local road category are not in it? (IOW would you expect these roads to just be slightly smaller or to be those narrow roads?)

@robryk Comparing with older N roads (say, the N2 to derry or the N59 in mayo), the older road is single lane each way, and has a lower speed limit (and thus tigher turns etc). They also go through towns etc. My expectation is the newer N roads look like the older. One reason I expect this is cost - 4 lanes presumbly cost twice two lanes.

@robryk One guess is safety - having a dual carringeway eliminates dangerous overtaking. Having a higher design speed also means that speeders are less dangerous as well.

Another guess is that it is a motorway, but the current gov doesn't want to build new motorways, so someone in the DoT did s/M/N/ on a bunch of plans.

A 3rd guess is corruption - give taxpayer money to road builders. then the question of demand doesn't matter.

@psn @robryk I always thought (from my observations arriving in 2007) that it was because the EU threw wads of cash at Ireland to build roads early in the 2000s.

Lots of nice, big, flash (and relatively empty) roads had prominent "funded by the EU" signs alongside them as I explored the place.

@mattb @robryk Yeah, having looked it up this was built in the tail end of the boom - opened in 2009. Still looks new, still empty.

@psn @robryk is Ireland following the Vision Zero guidelines? Either the speed limit needs to be lowered or the road needs to be improved to separate the cars from everything else?

@isomer @robryk A bunch of the vision zero stuff I’ve seen is looking at urban environments. The one advantage of this sort of road is you don’t dump through traffic into little towns and villages. There’s no legal ban on cycling or walking on an n road. In this case, the Waterford greenway is along the river just out of shot.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.