While "Alien" (1979) is widely considered to be among the most important sci-fi films of all time, it features an absolutely glaring, unforgivable error in its first scene.

The film opens as we slowly explore the dim bridge of the star freighter Nostromo, empty with its crew long in hibernation. We pan the creepy interior, which includes a classic bobbing duck toy busily bobbing into a small container of liquid. And ... wait a sec. Hold everything!

The crew is in hibernation. That appears to be an ordinary container of what is probably water, sitting alone, unconnected to any tubes, pipes, or other infrastructure. Any liquid in that container would evaporate completely in a matter of days. If the duck can't dip into liquid to moisten its beak, it will stop bobbing.

There's nobody around to refill that container, no sign of any mechanism to do so.

This shameful lack of realism could have ruined the entire film. Luckily, most people didn't notice this nightmarish error.

@lauren The liquid was frozen for most of the trip. It only thawed out when the life support systems came back online prior to the crew being revived.

@shac They didn't let the bridge freeze. Most of that equipment would have been ruined. Nice try though.

@lauren@mastodon.laurenweinstein.org @shac@ioc.exchange ... and someone would have needed to manually give the bobber the first tip to get it started.

Follow

@arth @lauren @shac

You could make it with a beak that doesn't conduct heat well, and let it freeze with the beak in the water :) (Then there might be enough water to keep it running when it's freed from the ice.)

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.