1/ This debate over the #debtceiling is stupid AF and I blame journalists on this one.
For long as I can remember, the debt ceiling has been framed as allowing congress to maintain the "power of the purse" by authorizing the president to increase the overall debt.
The reality is that the debt is created/maintained when the budget is *approved* by congress and signed off on by POTUS.
So what we have here is congress creating debt and then creating extensions to pay the bill.
That is incorrect since the Constitution recognizes that the appropriations power is distinct from borrowing authority.
It's also incorrect since the Treasury is the one that issues debt, not Congress. Wrong branch of government.
You talk about buying a TV on a credit card, but you're overlooking that in this analogy the TV has not yet been bought.
@volkris I’m not sure what you are getting at here.
14th amendment section 4 states:
“The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned”
Debts “authorized by law” have to be paid. And since you stipulated that it is the treasury that issues debt.. and the treasury is authorized to issue debt by law, it still needs to be paid.
@volkris https://www.cleveland.com/nation/2023/05/as-debt-ceiling-debate-rages-federal-workers-sue-in-bid-to-get-law-declared-unconstitutional.html
“in a Massachusetts federal court, argues that once spending is authorized by Congress and approved by the president, the executive branch lacks authority to pick and choose which spending will be honored.”
This lawsuit was filed today basically saying that in regards to the debt, it’s all or nothing and nothing isn’t an option due to section 4 of the 14th amendment
Right, and such arguments misunderstand how the federal government actually operates, if nothing else overlooking that the government NEVER actually spends exactly what Congress has authorized.
The executive branch clearly has the authority to pick and choose which spending will be honored seeing as it always does not to mention separation of powers not to mention this particular case where it literally cannot conduct the spending that has been permitted.
@volkris if that was the case, then we wouldn’t be trillions of dollars in debt.