@drewdevault

AFAIK any modification to LGPLv3 code must be distributed under LGPLv3.

The difference with GPL is that you can include or link an unmodified LGPL work into a proprietary software and distribute the whole with a different license.

But if you modify the LGPL work itself and redistribute it (in binary or source form) you must use the LGPL license as it would obviously be a derivative work.

Even wikipedia confirms this en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Le

Thus you should clarify the related paragraphs: using LGPL for the distribution of derivative works is not a suggestion but a requirement of the license.

Also, when I talked with a lawyer about a derivative work of a BSD software he explained me that I could distribute my modified version under AGPLv3 because I had introduced and modified several parts and my modification was under GPLv3 so the work as a whole was GPLv3, BUT I could not alter the copyright statements in the files I was copying verbatim from the original BSD project.

So my suggestion is to talk with a lawyer specialized in sofyware copyright about Redict before distributing Redis code under a different license.

@Shamar "using LGPL for the distribution of derivative works is not a suggestion but a requirement of the license"

This is wrong, there are ways to do this without creating a completely LGPL'd derivative work. But they're complicated and I didn't care to explain it on this page, which is made clear by the text.

Follow

@drewdevault

Any example?

Don't need to explain (I know the topic quite in depth) but I'd really like to see an example of a derivative work of a LGPL covered software that was not under LGPL.

I'll be happy to analyze it with my reference lawyer. Obviously, the more example, the better...

@Shamar you can release the parts derived from the LGPL source as well as a means of linking a modified version with your non-LGPL code

Which is why every LGPL shared library isn't a copyleft virus and is the raison d'être of the LGPL

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.