@aral
I'd say it's the other way around. Colonial is characterized by many small and new colonies spread out over large distances. Describes decentralized more than centralized.

@freemo @aral Colonialism is about centralised ownership, governance, and control. It's not about the geographical topology of the nodes but the network topology they're connected by. You can have the exact same geographical topology and have the network that connects those nodes be either centralised or decentralised. Centralised topologies imply centralised ownership, governance, and control. In other words, they are colonial.

@aral
While that's certainly a valid definition, even if we accept that definition I wouldn't say it describes centralized systems since there are no colonies, just a single uniform system. A better analogy might be libertarianism vs dictatorship.

Colonialism means that no matter how far you go, the same few people are in charge, and trying to extract yourself from this governance makes you an outcast. It was true for geography, but it still is true for social media for example. Decentralization means that you can actually choose your small-scale governance and still be able to communicate with other similar entities.
Follow

@hypolite @aral I disagree, that is not an accurate description of the meaning of colonialism.

Of course a few extremist have tried to twist the definition and have used it that way. But I dont think such people are really worth taking seriously usually (not saying this applies to you, I don't know you).

@hypolite @aral Same as the dictionary. A group of settlers from a foreign land basically.

You're thinking of colonization. Colonialism is an ideology, not the physical act itself. As such it can describe a wider range of practice and philosophy.

@hypolite @aral Colonialism is an ideology of performing and supporting colonization.

Yes, and its usage expanded to refer to more than geographical colonization. Now, if you don't want to talk about the actual subject using the words as they have been explained to you earlier, I suggest you just move along.

@hypolite @aral Of course, I never claimed it was specific to geographical.

I suggest you not worry about what people wish to discuss and that if you don't like what is being discussed then YOU should move on.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.