@posrev We dont even know if he existed, let alone have "real" dates... that said what historic source do you feel would dictate an october date?
@posrev Im not sure i follow. Why must it be fall if he was born in Bethlehem?
@posrev In 60 degree weather (the norm for Bethlehem in December) you'd expect animals to be outside and mary to be comfortable in a manger. 60 isnt that cold.
@posrev this is true, but thats true any time of the year really :)
@posrev I find all the holy texts, the bible, torah, qua'ran, Libri Quinti Mysterium, and the countless others to all be valuable and interesting reads. No doubt.
@posrev A quick search suggests there is no context in the bible for a date other than the star of bethleham which would suggest a date in spring based on the theory that it was a comet known to show around that time period.