What’s so depressing is that as a species if we wanted to we could wipe out SARS2 like we did with that strain of flu a couple of years ago. Imagine lifting everyone’s lives up with this one action. But no, better to pretend it’s all fine and keep getting sick while millions are denied any form of a life.

@andymoose

COVID research scientist here.

We cant and we didnt.

The flu strain from a couple years ago H1N1 is still alive and kicking just like SARS-COV- is

Neither was ever an option to eliminate entirely with current technology, we knew this very early on in our studies,

@DavidM_yeg

Ahh ok, yea in that case the yamagata strain was just replaced with two new active strains.

Nothing unusual about strains being replaced with new strains, that happens no matter what we do and seen several strains of covid be eliminated by that metric.

@andymoose

@andymoose @freemo

It wasn’t just that a somewhat obscure strain was eliminated… here in Alberta, we skipped an entire ‘flu season, with 0 lab recorded cases in 20-21. We weren’t “shut down”, we weren’t being locked away in isolation, we weren’t living pathetic lives that were only a shadow of their former selves: we were instead taking very simple common-sense precautions against airborne diseases.

@DavidM_yeg

If alberta wasnt in lockdown at a time that most of the world was, sadly thats not a great example either. You were more than likely benefiting off the rest of the worlds lock down and your own commons-sense methods likely helped to keep you further isolated but only protected you to the extreme you did due to worldwide lock downs.

@andymoose

@freemo @andymoose

Sorry the world was *not* in ‘lockdown’ during the ‘20-‘21 ‘flu season, especially our largest neighbour to the south …unless by ‘lockdown’ you mean ‘required masks in schools and public places’ in which case we shouldn’t continue this conversation.

@DavidM_yeg

In the USA the lockdown was maintained until August 2020. So the lockdown basically existed right up to the flu season. Were you expecting the flu to instantly spike back to baseline levels once lock down ends? It takes time for viruses to start spreading again, it isnt an instant process you know, and with the lockdowns literally ending right as flu season begins means you are going to have a much reduced incident.

Also you are flat out wrong about the 0 flu cases.

It wasn’t just that a somewhat obscure strain was eliminated… here in Alberta, we skipped an entire ‘flu season, with 0 lab recorded cases in 20-21.

Alberta’s 2021 flu season had 2,906 confirmed flu cases resuling in 523 hospitalizations. Anf thats just confirmed cases.

alberta.ca/influenza-the-flu

@andymoose

@freemo @andymoose

From that the website you just linked to…

0 lab confirmed cases from Aug 2020 to Aug 2021

@DavidM_yeg

This seems valid, my mistake. I was reading from the wrong column.

However now looking at the correct data it seems, and unspuprisingly, that 2022-023 has been the deadliest flu season on record for alberta. This goes to show the fundemental point, lockdowns will result in decline in numbers but **not** elimination. Once lock downs are removed the rates will come back up and even slyrocket and over time result in no real gains.

To put it in some perspective the 2023 flu

cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alb

@andymoose

@freemo @andymoose

I think we’re done.

My point is that when people adapt their movement patterns and take precautions against airborne spread, rates plummet. Maintaining the measures that work for long periods will mean long term reductions.

Continuing to use an inflammatory term like lockdown as a broad and blanket term for responsible measures is misleading.

@DavidM_yeg

I have clearly described what i mean by lockdown, and you aking up fictional things I said to win is childish to say the least.

I defined lockdown clearly as:

Just to be clear, no this isnt what I mean. I am talking about where movement itself is restricted (such as cancelling public events or shutting down non essential workplaces)

The fact that your having a tantrum about lockdown literally meaning restricted public movement and shutting down businesses is laughable.

You are right, we are done here.

@andymoose

Follow

@DavidM_yeg

I do find it funny though that you ignore all the actual facts when talking to an actual published COVID research scientists…. really showing your colors there.

But yea I’m the one being inflammatory, LOL

@andymoose

@DavidM_yeg

I never said I was a medical expert, I said I was a scientist... maybe you should look at my published papers instead, or even my resume.

I just finished inventing a decide capable of detecting covid on ones breath within a few minutes at little to no cost after leading a team of medical (clinical) and chemistry teams at a large lab in Israel.

Maybe you should ask, learn and research rather than accuse, it will go much further.

@andymoose

@DavidM_yeg

And for soem background the same team of medical and chemistry scientist had tried for 3 years and failed. I was called in and hired as a specialist and solved the same problem they couldnt in only 3 months.

I have proven myself, and that has been well published and proven by this point.

You are a waste of time, and every reply you prove that more.

@andymoose

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.