PKA making a very good case that Einstein plagiarized everything he's ever been famous for. Citing pre-existing papers and everything, sometimes decades before he published anything on the subject, with no citation.

What if Einstein was actually just an average ass patent dude who was good at copy-pasting?
@boob I've heard this before and it always seemed like the sort of thing that ought to be provable.
@Moon @boob regardless, even if this is true, that would be a very antisemitic argument and thus you all should just stop thinking about it
@roka @Moon Like, totally without looking into it myself, the guy didn't do *that* well in school, his primary trade wasn't academia, and aside from publishing papers, he never actually did much of anything in the realm of experiments or research. NGL I'm leaning toward Einstein being a hoax now, I'd never even considered it before but the idea of a patent employee being one of the greater minds of our era seems far fetched.
Follow

@roka @boob @Moon you do not become famous by solely inventing something, you become famous primarily by presenting yourself and your invention to your community in an acceptable/digestible/useful way and secondarily - random circumstance. If it is an issue, it is an issue with fame and recognition in general not Einstein. It is an issue with Einstein specifically, only if you consider him a prophet of a rival deity, which is a delusion irrelevant to the community en large.

· · SubwayTooter · 1 · 0 · 0
@namark @roka @Moon He plagiarised a ton of sources drafted by rival scientists and added nothing of his own.

@boob
For the purposes of this discussion I'm accepting your premise. He might as well have been so dumb as to render him incapable of expressing thoughts in any form. For a rational person this would be but a minor curiosity, yet another "victim" our natural tendency to create heroes and idols out of thin air. However for someone who is in that game of heroes and idols with political/ideological/religious agenda, this would be grand revelation, worth not only all the research and proof they can master, but also (why of course only just a pinch of) speculation.

There are no greater minds, there are just minds that happen to stumble upon something in a way that others happen to recognize at the moment.

@roka @Moon

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.