@ReverseModule@kafeneio.social @zate @servant @joel I'm with you in considering it unethical if no consense was given. I don't see you anywhere explaining why such list should be a massive mistake or a burden to mastodon. In your pinned post you just state that Mastodon cannot work with instances and that everyone should have his own personal instance.
I do not believe this idea of yours to be true, though I also have doubts that Mastodon can work on a large scale, but those kinds of problems will not be solved by everyone running their own instance, probably they'll be exacerbated by such behavior.

I don't agree with you, while I'm not going to use such list I believe it can be useful to some people who are new to Mastodon.
Moreover, the fact that you're using it contradicts your statement...
The list may be used to scam people, but also no list may be used to scam people. I see no reason to condemn it for it unless it is in fact used to scam people.