Thinking about how in the early versions of the Aladdin story, the genie -

the powerful entity that Aladdin and the Chinese Magician used to carry out their tasks, that acted in accordance with their instructions and had no self-motivation -

is not only an excellent metaphor for the kind of behavior that people want from AI

but was referred to textually as "the slave of the ring"

Very -explicitly- as a slave.

People who endorse the use of AI as a human replacement aren't looking for workers.

They're looking for slaves.

Yes, I am explicitly referring to the pre-Disney conception of the story.

Which, tracing the throughline, has some -really- uncomfortable implications for the Will Smith version that would have made that movie untenable without Robin Williams' remake of the character; Smith is basically doing a remake of Williams more than the origi....

Wait -Guy Ritchie- directed it?

Huh. I guess it is a kind of heist movie.

Y'ever read the 1001 Nights? There's some good shit in there that Disney's not got their grubby little mouse paws into.

Also there are -incredible- levels of recursion; you have frame tales within frame tales and stories within stories

Anyway, if you wanna run with this thought line, it's pretty easy to make the case that 'ai' has no place in a democracy from the angle that work without recompense or choice is antithetical to the rights that democracies are supposed to engage with and facilitate.

AI's really the distillation of the dreams of the slaveholding class, ain't it?

It's something you can tell to perform work without any of that pesky -negotiation- involved; no chance of it saying "no"; no need to seek that pesky -consent-.

Follow

@munin

Where would you put the line that distinguishes this kind of work and work of e.g. a water pump (which I assume you don't object to on similar grounds)? On "can be commanded using nontrivial expressions of natural language" maybe?

@robryk

Water pumps are obviously not thinking beings.

Something that communicates in natural language via the same mechanism that you can use to speak to other thinking beings has that pretense.

@robryk

Which, yes! I -do- have -severe- problems with alexa, google assistant, and IVR systems.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.