Where does your knowledge of what is right come from? Is it objective or subjective, internal or external?
What would the world be like if everyone else had the same way of knowing what is right?
@dclr42 I think it's something intrinsic in most humans. Working together to a greater goal is just.. something you know. You know killing other people for fun is not justice, because you'd harm your species that way. It doesn't matter whether you're religious or not, it is just... human.
@trinsec Cooperation is pretty basic, but "justice" seems like it's more abstract than species-benefit. Where does that value come from?
@dclr42 I'm not talking about the 'justice' that you know from laws. I'm talking about the justitious feeling in every human.
If you see a big bully hurting a smaller person just cause, you feel that this is 'not right'. It's the kind of feeling that makes people root for the underdogs.
Aggressive individuals in any species won't last long in general, because they are putting the whole species in danger. We're not that much different from other species in that regards.
@trinsec I think I see what you're getting at, but why is the impulse "defend the underdog" rather than "expel the bully?" Particularly, at a certain point bullies are able to achieve tribal dominance.
@trinsec Sorry to leave you hanging all weekend. I don't see a strong connection between a naturalistic explanation of the universe and things like justice. It seems like, for these things to exist, there has to be some kind of "higher power."