@Dahlialith This is a thoughtful and much-needed expression of concern about the (understandable) celebrations of #Moore. I'm even more worried about what's really meant by "ordinary bounds of judicial review" esp given what the CJ's announcement seemed to emphasize (in my memory, anyway). I could see some advocates hearing it as an invitation to argue for extending Rucho to state courts. #scotus
Follow
Honestly, the who situation had become such a mess, especially with the NC SC ruling late in the game, that such a vague conclusion was almost hard to avoid.
I'm with Thomas. This had become such a mess that it was no longer a solid vehicle for addressing the question. SCOTUS should have punted to avoid this sort of outcome.
