My read on #bluesky is that they are effectively sucking the air out of the decentralization balloon, whether they intend to or not. On the tech side, the #ATprotocol will prevent much decentralization from ever happening and divert the focus that was on #ActivityPub development. On the culture side, they deter a critical mass from developing here, which we need to overwhelm the influence of our most annoying users and lure in the people most people want to follow and interact with. #fediverse

@wjmaggos what about ATProtocol prevents decentralization?

From what I’ve read it promotes it better than the protocols here.

@volkris

my understanding is you don't get server to server interaction, but there's an intermediary. it's supposedly designed to make things easier at the edge of the network, but my skepticism leads me to think they will just end up being choke points.

it's hard to get people to care about decentralization. it basically has to be forced on us, or most of us will use Amazon etc. I worry about mastodon dot social for this reason too, but here it's almost like setting up WP. not with BS.

Follow

@wjmaggos I think that the AT protocol is MORE decentralized, not less, because of that: it decentralizes past servers/ instances, so that there’s less server to server interaction is a result of being less centralized around servers.

@volkris

I don't understand. it kinda sounds like you're talking about nostr. please elaborate.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.