volkris @volkris@qoto.org
I think the most pressing and fundamental problem of the day is that people lack a practically effective means of sorting out questions of fact in the larger world. We can hardly begin to discuss ways of addressing reality if we can't agree what reality even is, after all.
The institutions that have served this role in the past have dropped the ball, so the next best solution is talking to each other, particularly to those who disagree, to sort out conflicting claims.
Unfortunately, far too many actively oppose this, leaving all opposing claims untested. It's very regressive.
So that's my hobby, striving to understanding the arguments of all sides at least because it's interesting to see how mythologies are formed but also because maybe through that process we can all have our beliefs tested.
But if nothing else, social media platforms like this are chances to vent frustrations that on so many issues both sides are obviously wrong ;)
Joined Dec 2022
Really this is just fundamentally how decentralization works. This is how scaling works. This is mathematical, fundamental laws of physics sorts of things.
If you want true decentralization then it's going to be resource intensive. There is mathematically no avoiding that.
Fediverse is badly coded (IMO) but it tries to avoid these issues by not actually being decentralized. Federation means it's centralized around instances, not decentralized, but centralized around instances.
BlueSky proposes to fulfill the promise, but there is no avoiding that the promise comes with costs.
volkris
boosted
#Kilmeade, missing that he is potentially identifying the problem: To be a reporter traveling with the president is really rough because the guy doesn't sleep! He'll wander out and talk to the press anytime around the clock. He doesn't sleep! #Trump #USPolitics
@light Yeah, the options might not be easy, but at least there are options, unlike on fediverse where you're just screwed by the instance centralization.
That's the point.
It might be inconvenient, and maybe with time there can be systems to improve the user experience, but on fediverse there's just no way at all.
@hellomiakoda The problem is false information about what's going on in Portland.
We need to identify the root problem here, the false information. Complaining about the response to the falsehoods doesn't really fix it, it just papers over it and promotes the controversy.
@Teknevra Well that's exactly the reason not to do that.
Federation is honestly kind of stupid. Better to decentralize down to the user level and let users manage their experiences. There is no good reason to double down on centralizing around instances, and this is a fantastic illustration of why centralizing around instances is a dumb idea.
@mdione better: #USPolitics
There's no reason not to spell it out.
@cazabon More likely he did it just to get in the headlines, to get attention. It's really all he cares about.
volkris
boosted
@b7bird.bsky.social What in the world?
If you listen to the GOP they are solidly behind it.
@Hex absolutely not.
It's like saying that Trump flapping his arms failed to fly around the room is because of protesters. No, it's because his bullshit never had a chance in the first place.
In fact anti-fascist organizing gives him a leg up because he gets to run against it. It actually helps him. He's still going to fail because he doesn't have a chance because he's an idiot, but the anti-fascist organizing helps propel him a little bit farther than he would otherwise.
He would probably have never been re-elected without the anti-fascist organizing. It's a large part of what got him over that line of beating Harris.
Trump is going to fail because he's an idiot the same they way that he was convicted because he doesn't know how the legal system works, but the anti-fascist organizing is only supporting him as he uses it in campaign speeches to his crowd.
@realcaseyrollins you give the people what they want!
@hanspetermeyer congratulations, Canada, you just got a boondoggle.
@foxmental.bsky.social It's not a ruling
@lisagetspolitik What actions?
This seems pretty unlikely.
@tirrimas so they joined a federal program instead of a state program? Seems reasonable.
@rhys this seems kind of twisted and bizarre.
It seems to be an originalist argument against originalism. It seems to be saying originalism is a modern development by using originalist methods of analysis to look at originalism in the early days compared to the way originalism is talked about now.
So it seems self-defeating.
Conservative media: #Trump is awesome! When you're covering him on a trip it's hard because he doesn't sleep, he comes out anytime day or night to talk to you!
Me: oh well that might be what's so screwed up about him. The dude is constantly brain dead exhausted.
@light you say "can always choose another instance" as if that's trivial. But it amounts to a much more serious banning than being removed from PLC when there are other options to replace that.
This is exactly an example of how BlueSky is more decentralized than Fediverse.
Fediverse requires that connection to an instance which can ban you while ATProto doesn't. It provides alternatives to prevent that centralization.
I think the most pressing and fundamental problem of the day is that people lack a practically effective means of sorting out questions of fact in the larger world. We can hardly begin to discuss ways of addressing reality if we can't agree what reality even is, after all.
The institutions that have served this role in the past have dropped the ball, so the next best solution is talking to each other, particularly to those who disagree, to sort out conflicting claims.
Unfortunately, far too many actively oppose this, leaving all opposing claims untested. It's very regressive.
So that's my hobby, striving to understanding the arguments of all sides at least because it's interesting to see how mythologies are formed but also because maybe through that process we can all have our beliefs tested.
But if nothing else, social media platforms like this are chances to vent frustrations that on so many issues both sides are obviously wrong ;)
Joined Dec 2022
volkris's choices:
