Looks like my stort of style. but I think im happy leaving it at qtile and i3 (spent enough time playing with this).. Plus while qtile is my favorite i3 is the most popular so I feel I've covered my bases with those two choices.
How much i enjoy it will basically boil down to how easy it is to get it looking nice, and how far i can take that.
@freemo @johnlitt it's a manual TWM and is pretty nice http://herbstluftwm.org/