@JonKramer @godpod the state has billions of dollars in order to spend it on services. A billionaire has no such responsibility. One can debate the extent to which a particular state spends its money wisely, how corrupt it is, and how much money it should have in the first place, but I don't see how billionaires and states are in any way equivalent.

@joat @godpod they aren't. States generate their funds by force. Billionaires generate their funds by selling products someone wants to buy. I would agree that billionaires that sell to states shouldn't exist... outlaw selling weapons and building prisons, for example... but a someone who gets rich selling things people want? I LOVE those guys. And to get rid of them, just stop buying from them.

@JonKramer @joat @godpod no, people don't always have a choice-- monopolism happens a lot these days, especially in industries where billionaires are created. Nobody "earns" a billion dollars.

Also, taxes are the cost of having a society. Libertarians are often asked whether they use government services such as roads and fire departments and many other things, but they never seem to have a good answer.

@jamesmarshall @joat @godpod monopolies are enforced by the state. I agree, that is a problem. Who do you suggest we arrest first?

@JonKramer @joat @godpod anti-monopolism hasn't been enforced in the US since the 1970s. Go after Big Tech, mostly run by monopolistic billionaires.

@jamesmarshall @joat @godpod are you trying to say that monopolies are NOT created by the state??

@JonKramer @joat @godpod yes, monopolies are not created by the state. They are created by monopolistic behavior on the part of psychopathic CEOs. The state is (or is supposed to be) protection against the abuse of concentrated power by such people.

@jamesmarshall @joat @godpod I honestly don't know how to address your post. Monopolies tend to have two forms, natural or legal. Natural Monopolies really can not be broken up. And the other ones are legal ones created by the state.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.