Calling free software "free as in free speech" is such an insidious conflation because free speech is about the government not constricting your speech, especially political speech. It's not the same thing at all as the freedom espoused by free software because there is no requirement in free speech to make your speech public, to let the world see it and change it, or to let them use it for whatever purpose they like. In fact, the privacy of speech is central to free speech.

Follow

@ljwrites

While this is the smartest objection to my usual comparison of free software and free speech, I think you are missing an important detail.

is a work-aroud to defeat unjust laws.

If I take code (or executables, it doesn't change much), modify it and publicily share the result under any form, I'm going to be criminalised and actually indicted for copyright infridgement.

Now for a , programming is a form of expression just like writing is for everybody else.

International copyright laws and agreements is basically statal censorship for economical (thus ideological and political) gain.

Now, one might argue that are a tiny minority that do not deserve such right to expression and it have to sacrify it for the other mainstream programmers.

And it's surely true that the people did their best to take Free Software from hackers to turn it into an exploitative, ethically washed, tool.

And I agree that, because of that, we are reaching the limits of what a licence, however strong, can protect.

For example, thanks to the progress of , we can all see that all free software copyleft forgot the right (duty?) to .

But free software still stands as a tool to create a protected zone of free programming expression in a hostil environment ruled by (corporate friendly) copyright law.

Since copyright infrigement can lead hackers to statal jail, free software IS free speech.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.