Something random-

I've been reading up on ancient Canaanite religion recently, and it is a very interesting subject. Particularly when you look at it as the precursor religion to what would eventually become Judaism.

A lot of the god names are maintained in Hebrew- which is, itself, a Canaanite language- the only living (Although you could say resurrected) Canaanite language. Yam (long A, Yaam) for instance is one that is super easy to spot because the word, in Hebrew, for ocean is still yam.

It's a very interesting thing to study for me, as a Jewish person and a secular Zionist who ascribes to the notion that the Jewish people are the aboriginal people to the region of the world I've chosen to make my home.

However, from a history standpoint it's particularly interesting to see where my culture and the religion associated with said culture came from and evolved from.

@Surasanji I am not jewish but I love geeking over Hebrew and other religions. While I know far less than an expert ont he subject Hebrew /Judaism is one of my favorite topics, particularly when discussing it in the form it had a few thousand years ago.

@freemo It's a really interesting thing, but I'm biased due to my personal connection.

Of particular interest is that at one point, before the Babylonian captivity, the religion that would later become Judaism was most likely monolatristic . That is to say that they worshiped one god over all the other gods- they still had a polythestic pantheon. The king was the head of the religion, and had the divine right thing going.

You can see this in some of the wording which even survives until today. References to foreign gods 'The gods of Egypt' or how the ten commandments is often translated 'No other gods before me'.

The Babylonians roll in, though, and take into captivity all the movers and shakers- the priests, the wealthy, the nobility- and the religion undergoes a major change in those years.

@surasanji didn't the Sumarian/Babylonians believe their gods were giant aliens?

No clue. I haven't really been studying ancient Babylonian religion. However, the pattern in the ancient religions I've looked into seems more in line with the anthropomorphism of natural forces, philosophical concepts, and attempts to explain things that were not yet fully understood.

I'm no expert though. Just someone who really finds this stuff interesting.

@surasanji  anthropomorphism is the narrative that modern man has attributed to ancient societies. How do you think current documents will be interpreted 10k yrs from now?

@js290 I'm not sure I'd classify it as a narrative. The personification of that which we don't understand seems to be a fairly natural response to those things we can't explain.

Taking, for instance, ancient religions- you have concepts such as war, or avatars of storms and lightning. Gods of the ocean, or of fertility and crops.

We began to explain our world and our place in it through the observations we could make with the tools we had in that particular time. The questions of why we are, what we are, where we are, and how everything works are questions that humanity has been asking itself for as long as we've been able to do so.

It is in our nature to give human characteristics even to things we do understand. People ascribe human elements to their vehicles (cars, or boats in particular), or to their pets for instance.

You can also see elements of this personification of things in language and how we communicate. Some languages ascribe gender to objects, as an example.

As for how we'll be viewed in the eyes of history? I'm not sure, I don't really have an answer for how the world will be ten thousand years down the line. That is a really, really long time. I can only hope that historians ten thousand years from now remember me, personally, as handsome and a nice guy.

@surasanji re:"personification of that which we don't understand..." Isn't that precisely what we moderns do with the ancients? Did the ancients have a better understanding of their time than we do of the historical records of their time?

@js290 Well, not really. We're not personifying ancient people because they are people. We're not giving them person-like traits they didn't actually have because they were human beings like us, and undoubtedly led as rich and interesting lives as any other human being does today.

It is true that we don't fully understand many ancient peoples. We don't know why they did certain things, and the whens of particular historical events can get exceedingly muddy the further back you go. All we can do is make an educated guess based on what evidence we do find.

Bringing it back to Ancient Canaanite religion- there isn't an awful lot known about it. The ancient Canaanites seem to have taken papyrus paper from their Egyptian neighbors as their preferred writing medium and most of the contemporary writings to those eras are lost or remain as of yet undiscovered.

Most of what we do know is traced back through the surviving children of the Canaanites- Jewish and Samaritan histories and religious texts, which are perhaps not the most honest of historical sources, and from cuneiform tablets found in Ugarit.

The rest is pieced together from later Greek sources.

That being said, there is a lot more about ancient human societies and cultures that we don't know than we do. We're making our best guess based on those shreds of evidence that have survived (sometimes) thousands of years.

It's a puzzle we'll likely never fully solve.

@Surasanji @js290
We can surmise that — like pre-Torah Judean and Israelites — it probably bore resemblance to other Levantine people's religion, with a regional or endemic version of Amarutu/Bel/Ba'al and/or Astarte. Yhvh began as a henotheistic tribal deity, the local version of Marduk or Ba'al.

@KingTherapy @js290 The Canaanite people each had their own little kingdoms and they were apparently not at all afraid to pull culturally, technologically, and religiously from their neighbors. There was almost certainly some amount of trade in that manner.

Those kingdoms seem to have been organized around what I guess you could call a patron deity within the accepted deities of the region.

As the only surviving Canaanite language, Hebrew is a very interesting look into that past- and many place names have remained the same in this region since antiquity, carrying on their connection to ancient gods and folk heroes of a people who are for the most part remembered as villains in modern "religious history".

Interesting point on the word 'Ba'al'. Still used in modern Hebrew. It means husband, although literally is translated as 'Master'.

@Surasanji @js290
Yeah. 'Arabic, too. Like the English "Mister" and French "Monsieur".

@KingTherapy @js290 To a certain degree. Arabic isn't descended from a Canaanite language- but both Hebrew and Arabic are part of the Semetic language family, albeit from slightly different branches. There are some fairly major similarities I think it would be best to call them 'Cousins' in terms of relations.

It's important to note that Modern Hebrew is a revived language and is at least partially constructed. There are tons of loanwords in modern Hebrew for anything that the biblical and religiously maintained Hebrew just didn't have words that were close enough for. Modern Hebrew. There are a lot of Slavic, Romance, and Germanic influences in modern Hebrew that were specifically added to ensure the language could cope with the reality of the modern world.

@js290 @KingTherapy

That is an interesting article, but it's got a tone that's suuuuper condescending and insulting.

@Surasanji @js290
People’s National chauvinism is often enforced through brusque condescension. God, Iranians are as bad as the French, even if they are more often right in their biases!

@Surasanji @js290 Yes, I know that revived Hebrew as spoken, even conforms grammatically to patterns derived from European languages of the diaspora.

Read some good recent research, mapping origins of ‘Arabic to Levant and NW coast of Arabian peninsula. Contrasting the other tribes of Hijaz Sabaa and Yathrib as being “Non Arab” Semitic, with related Afro-Asiatic languages in pre Islamic antiquity.

Worth more looking for me.

@KingTherapy @js290 Yeah, absolutely. I haven't done a ton of research into Arabic's past, but I'd imagine it is a very interesting linguistic history. The language is widely spoken, and I'm under the impression it isn't all mutually intelligible despite being mostly classified by many scholars as being the same language.

@Surasanji @js290
The use of Nabatean script amongst pre-Hejira era languages has been confusing this scholarship, especially with so few surviving examples.

It’s fascinating to me, but just an abiding side interest.

@KingTherapy @js290 I will absolutely have to look into that. Speaking of the Nabateans, I'm planning a trip to Avdat sometime soon. Probably in the winter when it isn't quite so disgustingly hot.

@Surasanji Why do you believe it is in our nature to give these characteristics? Is this a deep rooted, narcissistic tendency? Or do you think it is a coping mechanism for the unknown and we assign what we are comfortable with, humanity?

@js290 @Surasanji I'm not sure I've heard that anywhere except the History Channel.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
QOTO Mastodon

Welcome to the QOTO instance

QOTO: Question Others, Teach Others

A Mastodon instance for scholars in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) and all yearning to learn.

A free speech space. No censorship here.
We do not silence or block any instances.

Unique Features
  • Inline math Latex support - Use \ ( and \ ) for inline LaTeX, and \ [ and \ ] for display mode.
  • 65,535 character limit for toots (usually 500)
  • 65,535 character limit for profile bio (usually 160)
  • Full text searches - usually you can only search hashtags and usernames
  • Halcyon / Twitter clone front-end - Want the interface to look exactly like the Twitter interface? After you signed up just go here to login:
  • PeerTube - We host our own PeerTube server with open registration for up to 100MB, but all of our active users get unlimited quotas. Sign up here:
  • Professionally hosted with nightly backups
  • light modern theme with full width columns (not fixed)
  • Several extra themes - including mastodon default and mastodon default with full width columns (not fixed)

Message to New Members

Welcome to the Qoto Mastodon instance, its like twitter but better!

Please don't hesitate to Direct Message me or tag me in Toots (what we call tweets here) if you have any questions or even if you just want to chat.

If you are new to Mastodon you may want to check out this official getting started guide:

We are a free speech, no censorship zone. Feel free to talk about whatever you want, say whatever you want, as long as it is legal you wont ever get banned from the server. With that said we do have a few rules: No spam, and no using multiple accounts to circumvent personal bans.

This server isnt a typical mastodon server either. I have personally modified the code on this server to give it several unique features you wont find on other servers.

If you are new to Mastodon here is some useful info.

First off, if your coming from Twitter and you'd prefer an interface that looks exactly like twitter, then just go here and login with your Qoto credential: No need to create an account there, your account on this server will work just fine. Just enter your username in the following format @[username] so for me it would be @freemo But personally I think our default skin here is way better.

Basically Mastodon is a decentralized twitter. That means anyone can run a server (like Qoto) that people can sign up to and use just like twitter. The unique part is how the servers talk to each other.

If you want to tag someone on the same server as you then you can just do @user however if you want to specify someone on a different server you can do @user@server. If someone follows you or mentions you on any server on the internet you'll get notified right here. So my full tag is

So now a bit about the timelines, there are three (unlike twitter there is just one): Home, Local, Federated.

The Home timeline is just like what you'd expect on twitter, that is, everyone you are following.

The local timeline is any post made by anyone on your local server.

The federated timeline is what is cool. It combines the timeline of everyone on the server into one. This way you can see the posts of everyone that is followed by anyone on the server (assuming the post is public). So this timeline is a close representation of everyone on the internet who has Mastadon (though not really). Moreover we have a bot here that goes around and federates with everyone it can find, so our Federated Feed is rather robust covering thousands of instances.

Only other thing that is unique is listed vs unlisted posts. You have normal privacy settings like on twitter but you also can set a post to be listed or unlisted. If it is listed it acts just as i described. If it is unlisted then it acts just as a normal tweet would but it doesnt show up on local or federated timelines anywhere.

Also this goes without saying, but don't be racist, sexist, hateful, and don't harass people. Its a pretty shitty thing to do, don't be shitty!

The following is the list of QOTO administrators/moderators.
Note: The account listed as the administrator is NOT an actively monitored account. It was selected so as not to show favoritism among our moderator group, we are a democracy and even our administrators and moderators are held to the same high standards of decency as the rest of the community.

***We will never advertise on QOTO or sell your information to third-parties***