Follow

@reverend
consider:

- we don't have a free market here. everything is overregulated. half of income gets extracted and then put into companies who did the best "lobbying" (bribes).
- measuring success by "high speed train exists" is a fallacy. those prestige projects always work in collectivist systems, that's why the pyramids exist. just takes enough resources and people to make the problem go away. keeping the high speed trains going over decades is where it is.
- china isn't successful because of communism, it's successful for allowing just enough capitalist flexibility to sell things to the west and by ignoring effects on people and environment.

@bonifartius Yes, of course. It's just provocation. For years, we've been listening to the arrogant babbling of the feudal Western Europeans who have been dumbed down. I like everything that annoys them. And yes, China is not communism. But there are no free markets either. Even if there were, accumulation would inevitably set in. And with it, centralisation and monopoly.

@begsby ja waren einige Chomsky - Zizek zwei meiner großen idole .. naja...................

@begsby ich seh es wie bei den Bands: Irgendwann wird jeder ein kommerzieller Verräter. Dann sagt man halt - die erste Platte war geil. Nur die erste.

@begsby @reverend die meisten picken sich bei mises usw. auch nur raus was ihnen passt, genauso wie die anderen sich die "schönen teile" vom kommunismus aussuchen.. für mich gewinnt wer ohne gewalt auskommt, und das tut nur der freie markt.

@begsby @reverend @bonifartius@qoto.org

Das war jetzt sehr erfreulich anzuhören. =)

@reverend
> feudal Western Europeans

that's about the feeling yeah

> Even if there were, accumulation would inevitably set in. And with it, centralisation and monopoly.

i don't think it would to this extend without entities redistributing money. microsoft for example got this big by raking in governmental license fees. they are very protective of this, cf. the limux project which effectively got killed by what they call "lobbying".

a counter example is that i can select from 4 or 5 local bakers. they weren't killed by the big industrial scale ones, not even in the last years. same goes for many other things here. a free market doesn't only use "cheapest per unit" for value, but whatever those involved put value on for whatever reason. apparently people like good quality and supporting local business and put value on it.

@bonifartius @reverend china isn't even really communist, it's a managed capitalism das kapital speedrun to someday transition to actual communism

@sun As I said before, that's meant to be provocative, not true. I just like the sound of hyperventilation.

@sun @reverend what's stange is that there is chinese stuff which seems to be priced fair. solid product, without insane but fair profit. wonder how the price would be if they wouldn't have to price in the communist enterprise.

@sun @reverend one got to admit them that they fixed their "everyone is starving" problem while becoming the factory for the world. i don't think it's due to their socialism though.

@istvan @reverend only real green energy is small scale (like, for a farm) wind or water power. or maybe one of the solar panels that were described in low tech magazine.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.