You can keep your beliefs, but I’ll take empirical observation… especially observation confirmed by others and that accurately predicts other observations.
One thing I learned during 35 years in education: it’s almost impossible to differentiate those who did well in prerequisites from those who did not by looking at current performance.
I played trumpet for about 3 months in elementary school. I learned a lot about how not to teach from the music teacher. (This is a comment about an individual, not a generalization.)
It appears certain types of teaching (e.g. basic knowledge we can tell and test) can be best done by AI. I still see many teachers who believe this is their role.
I think it’s time we start asking candidates for leadership positions to “describe one time your decisions added to institutional drama and what you did to minimize it afterwards.”