my waves professor is so funny
someone asked him why the models we use only work for small amplitudes and he said
"well, i'll demonstrate!"

then he started slowy sliding a tub of water back and forth harder and harder until it spilled all over the desk and on his clothes

"uh oh!!!!
... does that answer your question"

Follow

@imyxh Eh, that's somewhat misleading. There are things that break way earlier than at such a discontinuous transition: things become nonlinear (e.g. the pendulum's period being independent of amplitude is only true in small amplitudes).

@robryk I believe you missed the joke, it's not "discontinuous transition", but "my clothes would get wet". :P @imyxh

@timorl Well, but that's a consequence of the discontinuity. I wanted to say that things break down way earlier than that (for waves in a container, when they're a nontrivial fraction of the water depth the things are way past breaking down). @imyxh

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.