@freemo @hansw Okay - so it sounds like the circle members get "baked in" at post time; the post doesn't just reference the circle - which may contain different members at lookup time from at post time. Am I interpreting this correctly?

@khird

Yes thats correct, whoever can see it at the time of post is fixed unless you edit the post.

@hansw

@freemo @hansw Thanks! Now if only we could get an "inherit audience" option for replies, which retrieves the audience of the parent comment and bakes *that* in as the audience for the reply ;)

Right now followers-only is kind of crappy because if you make a followers-only post, by default my reply will be followers-only. So people who follow you but not me, or me but not you, get a fragmented conversation view.

@khird

Yea, though for that we need the clients to play along too, so its harder to solve.

@hansw