@peterdrake possibly dumb idea: label the answer candidates with colours instead of or in addition to letters and use an Uno deck, which would be enough for 25 students after removing the wild cards. Looks like they generally retail for about 6USD. There's a version called ColorADD in case some students are colourblind, but I think the shades are sufficiently different it shouldn't pose much of a barrier to accessibility if you just use a normal deck.
@khird Not a bad idea at all -- I was starting to consider that already.
The ColorADD version is neat, but appears to be currently unavailable. It looks like it just adds a symbol to each color. If a colorblind students gets a blue 1, a red 2, a green 3, and a yellow 4, that could work just as well.