Which feels most natural to you?

@noelle

"no one" is the only one of these that is actually correct. So gonna have to go with that one.

@luna @noelle

Yup I sure am, and you will find our real quick so is the rest of the world the moment you try to write anything technical or professional.

Now if you wish to break the rules for the sake of art or beauty, or just for fun, by all means go for it.

@freemo @noelle As is expected from your instance for elitist, privileged assholes. Fuck off and stop claiming to support trans people in your pinned post if you're going to support things that go hand in hand with transphobia.

@luna

What in the world sort of nonsense is this... We werent even talking about anything remotely related to trans rights and I have always been a **very** vocal supporter of trans-rights (as are most from my instance)... what are you even on about with this nonsense.

@noelle

@freemo I'm sure any trans person would tell you prescriptivism is directly anti-trans and is actively being used against us. Kindly fuck off and start listening to us and taking action, changing your beliefs instead of saying empty performative words

Follow

@luna @freemo That people may have used prescriptivism in anti-trans agendas does not make prescriptivism itself anti-trans.

That's akin to saying that books are anti-gay because somebody wrote an anti-gay book once.

The logic simply doesn't follow.

ยท ยท 1 ยท 1 ยท 2

@LouisIngenthron

Exactly. I even recognized that im sure there are people out there using "proper english" as a bat with which to beat transpeople with (re: gender pronouns). But saying that means anyone who uses or believes English has rules is automatically anti-trans is just laughable.

@luna

@freemo @LouisIngenthron @luna I don't think it's necessarily anti-trans to think there's a proper way to use grammar, although if someone's pedantic within this particular context, then it might be irksome.

Someone quibbled with me once over "they", because that wasn't proper English, although that was around a decade ago.

No one does it to me now, although maybe I just interact with people who're somewhat nice.

I've always found a utility to it. When you're on the Internet, who knows what someone's gender is. It never made sense to me to assume everyone's a "man".

Since some feel more comfortable being addressed with it, that's another good attribute for it.

That makes a lot of sense to me too. Perhaps, someone isn't comfortable with either the she / he pronoun, or a particular gender role.

Language is an evolving thing, and maybe, there isn't a fixed way to do things, but I can see why you'd want a consistent standard for many things in a professional setting.

@olives

As I said in my response to this person, I have absolutely no issue with the claim that "proper english" is sometimes used against trans people when discussing pronouns...

The issue is that is so peripheral to the discussion, which wasnt about pronouns at all, as to be absurdist to equate what I said to the issue at all.

@LouisIngenthron @luna

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.