“What important truth do very few people agree with you on?”

(living thread)

Everything is quantifiable, and should be quantified.

Everything is a or can be measured.

can study anything, and is the language of science.

The fact that some aspects of life seem hard to estimate doesn’t mean we are better off not even trying and coming up with our best approximation.

More rarely hurts, and even rough approximations (accompanied by their respective confidence intervals) are useful information.

One can measure, weigh and analyse… and still be sensitive, funny, romantic, impressionable, intuitive, creative — if one so chooses after all the (numeric) information is available.

Show thread
Follow

@tripu I have some issues with measuring and quantifying everything.

In theory, having lots of data sounds nice. But in practice, some problems tend to come up:

  • Data quality. Even if you do your best, collecting all possible data would stop you from excluding data with questionable accuracy. If you add a score for “quality”, the meaning of that would evolve, and the task would become recursive without an end condition.

  • Chilling effects. If you collect data that might possibly be deanonymized (or is personal from the start), people will experience anxiety over what you do with this data. Even if you are trusted, any data collected can become public with security breaches. I would equate unbridled data collection to inflicting suffering.

  • Extra problem: deanonymization. If you collect more and more data, surprising ways to deanonymize data can come up.

  • Overwhelming amounts of data. If you have more data than you can even roughly comprehend, how would you process it? Machine learning demonstrates this from time to time by coming up with surprising results. But since we have no idea how those results were achieved, they are worthless. Could be a mistake, a correlation and not a causation… without comprehension knowledge is meaningless. I think of this in terms of the distinction between intelligence and wisdom.

If you meant that we should strive to collect data that is meaningful to solve specific problems i totally agree. Thoughts?

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.