@Umbr4R3d @ChristophB @garyackerman I guess there is something wrong with the testing regime as well. Students/pupils should be allowed to demonstrate their skills and competencies in ways that makes this whole scenario go away.
The Turing Test poisoned the minds of generations of AI enthusiasts, because its criteria is producing text that persuades observers it was written by a human.
The result? Generative AI text products designed to "appear real" rather than produce accurate or ethical outputs.
It *should* be obvious why it's problematic to create a piece of software that excels at persuasion without concern for accuracy, honesty or ethics. But apparently it's not.
“Every kid starts out as a natural-born scientist, and then we beat it out of them. A few trickle through the system with their wonder and enthusiasm for science intact.”
— Carl Sagan
@margreta @garyackerman I wonder if the situation I characterise here: https://davelane.nz/explainer-digitech-risks-school-boards also applies where you are... I suspect it's fairly universal, and it's a very big elephant in the room.
A union has voted “work to rule,” so folks have been declining invitations to committee meetings. While I’m no longer in the union, I fully support the decision.
I do have to convince colleagues that suggesting, “I’ll get your input in an individual meetings” is really not an appropriate response to those who skip extra committee work as part of collective action.
Worth a read! #Edtech has changed. I’m wondering what might be abandoned.
@garyackerman I would add the word “challenge” to “change.” If they (we!) are not challenged, how can we be encouraged to change?
Education is about changing humans. When our students leave our classrooms, we expect they can do things, see things, and think things they could not before the class. If our students leave with their abilities unchanged, then they (and we) have wasted their time and energy and money while there.
#edutooter #education #teaching
John Dewey wrote education is not preparation for life, it is life itself. While this may be true, many students enroll in higher education to be better prepared for the profession they will enter after they graduate. It seems reasonable, then, that educators should take steps to ensure their students can use what they learn in the classroom in other settings as well. #edutooter #education #highered
Director of Teaching and Learning Innovation at a community college in New England
Retired k-12 science/ math/ technology teacher/ technology integration specialist/ coordinator