@toplesstopics Hi, there is an initiative for a new server list underway and i see an issue with a proposed rule. The thing is that nudity and pornography are proposed to be treated the same, and that feels wrong.
I thought before i say something, you might be a lot more qualified to propose a better solution. I hope this is a reasonable request, if so please share your thoughts on this.
Easy to read pdf:
https://jeffreyfreeman.me/files/united_federation_of_instances_proposal.pdf
Please see chapter 3, rule 6 for what i mean.
Github repo:
https://gitlab.com/ufoi/constitution/-/blob/master/proposal.tex
(line 173 is what i mean, currently:
\item Nudity and pornography must be posted either unlisted, with a content warning, or both.)
@admitsWrongIfProven @toplesstopics @freemo
As a philosopher, I can think of many different ways to cash out the differences between nudity and pornography but perhaps one of the best ways centers around the idea of bodies as normalized aspects of human existence, rather than focusing on them for specific purposes that we might, as a server community, agree are not suited to the specific environment we wish to create here (on the server). For instance, pornography is the use of human nudity to create sexual excitement and gratification. If we all agreed that human nudity that is being used to create sexual excitement and gratification should not be permitted on this server, then other forms of nudity should not be prohibited unless we have other rules prohibiting the use of nudity for that purpose. Ultimately, we cannot control what people do with any nudity that might be shared here for other purposes, but we have created an express rule that should allow for moderation of nudity that appears to be shared for a purpose we have deemed in appropriate on the server.
