That’s me (or who I aspire to be) right there!

“I didn’t expect you to be interested. I’ll just be standing over here in the corner in case you decide you like truth and goodness.”

astralcodexten.substack.com/p/

@tripu I knew you would like that character 😆 scientifically engineering public holidays based on the optimal number of yearly breaks for an average number of hours/week and an average amount of stress/hour. Sounds like a dystopia!

@ImperfectIdea @tripu and as always dystopia is pitched as truth and goodness

Follow

@valleyforge

I understand that you (implicitly) saying that [our claim that festivities should/could be redesigned is bad] is something that you consider “good” and closer to the “truth” (otherwise you wouldn’t be defending it), and thus by your own assessment it risks devolving into a dystopia?

/cc @ImperfectIdea

@tripu @ImperfectIdea i think that sort of rational materialism leads to dystopia

@valleyforge

It’s a risk, yes.

Anyway, we’re talking shifting a few dates around to better accommodate modern sensibilities and preferences here, not burning down the regime.

Again (and I’m not trying to be facetious here): it is rationality (and I would argue also materialism) what you are using to conclude that any reform proposal risks devolving into a dystopia.

The polar opposite (keeping holidays just as they are) is essentially conservative and status quo bias.

Where’s the middle ground?

/cc @ImperfectIdea

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.