Comment on "Hilbert's Sixth Problem: Derivation of Fluid Equations via Boltzmann's Kinetic Theory" by Deng, Hani, and Ma arxiv.org/abs/2504.06297

Comment on "Hilbert's Sixth Problem: Derivation of Fluid Equations via Boltzmann's Kinetic Theory" by Deng, Hani, and Ma

Deng, Hani, and Ma [arXiv:2503.01800] claim to resolve Hilbert's Sixth Problem by deriving the Navier-Stokes-Fourier equations from Newtonian mechanics via an iterated limit: a Boltzmann-Grad limit (\(\varepsilon \to 0\), \(N \varepsilon^{d-1} = α\) fixed) yielding the Boltzmann equation, followed by a hydrodynamic limit (\(α\to \infty\)) to obtain fluid dynamics. Though mathematically rigorous, their approach harbors two critical physical flaws. First, the vanishing volume fraction (\(N \varepsilon^d \to 0\)) confines the system to a dilute gas, incapable of embodying dense fluid properties even as \(α\) scales, rendering the resulting equations a rescaled gas model rather than a true continuum. Second, the Boltzmann equation's reliance on molecular chaos collapses in fluid-like regimes, where recollisions and correlations invalidate its derivation from Newtonian dynamics. These inconsistencies expose a disconnect between the formalism and the physical essence of fluids, failing to capture emergent, density-driven phenomena central to Hilbert's vision. We contend that the Sixth Problem remains open, urging a rethink of classical kinetic theory's limits and the exploration of alternative frameworks to unify microscale mechanics with macroscale fluid behavior.

arXiv.org

Decoding the Ishango Bone: Unveiling Prehistoric Mathematical Art arxiv.org/abs/2504.06412

Decoding the Ishango Bone: Unveiling Prehistoric Mathematical Art

The Ishango Bone, discovered in 1950 near the Semliki River in present-day Democratic Republic of Congo and dated to over 24,000 years ago, features a series of 16 grouped numerical notches arranged across three columns. The interpretation of these markings has long been debated, ranging from numerical intention to decorative symbolism. This study presents a newly identified structural pattern, uncovering four irregularities in the numerical groupings that, when resolved, reveal a consistent internal logic across all three columns. The analysis identifies repeating sums, dualistic pairing structures, and cross-column symmetry, pointing toward a deliberate and complex mathematical arrangement. These findings suggest the notches may have functioned as a form of reference system, potentially using stone markers for visual or narrative purposes. Hypotheses include links to cosmic cycles, mathematical instruction, or mythological integration. While interpretations remain speculative, this study argues for an interdisciplinary reevaluation of the Ishango Bone's significance in terms of mathematical, cultural, and cosmological understanding. It offers new insights into the symbolic thinking and cognitive capacities of prehistoric societies and challenges conventional assumptions about the origins of numeracy.

arXiv.org
Show older
Qoto Mastodon

QOTO: Question Others to Teach Ourselves
An inclusive, Academic Freedom, instance
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.