@garyackerman
Hey its is more 'fun' than that. (AKA even more cyclical)
Consider 3 educational institutions, it is entirely plausible (has been observed to occur)
That 'A' is using program 'a', B is using program 'b' and C is using program 'c'
all of these are >>accurately<< observed to be ... failing
They all swap to new 'better' programs...
A is now using program 'b', B is now using program 'c' and C is using program 'a'
and all are again >>accurately<< observed to now be much better than before.
Education is an interpersonal process (not bucket chemistry). How a new and exciting the program is (feels) for the humans implementing the program has substantial effect on how well the program works. And it might be tempting to want to "fix" that but the people implementing the programs are indeed people, and how enthusiastic they are, is TBMK the actual most important factor in how well the programs work.
If they continue to cycle through programs a,b,c for all eternity and it continues to produce "improvements" (followed by inevitable decay/boredom) then there isn't actually a problem with that.
One of the most surprising realizations for adults who begin working in schools is that what is taught is not what they were taught or what they think should be taught. Curriculum is a part of school that is affected by many factors; some are very local (individual teachers are ultimately responsible for what it taught in their classrooms), others are school-wide or district-wide, yet others are state-wide or national. In the United States, there is no nationally mandated curriculum, and concepts like “fourth grade mathematics” are variable and open to interpretation.
Educational reform tends to follow a cycle that is familiar to many:
First, an initiative (supported with little or dubious evidence from the learning sciences) is introduced and implemented (with little or dubious support and rationale).
Second, problems with the initiative appear. These can originate from poor or incomplete implementation or support, discrepancies between the practices and human nature, or other difficulties.
Third, the initiative is recognized as failing, but remains in place (or is replaced with previously used methods under the vocabulary of the initiative).
Fourth, a new initiative replaced the old and the cycle repeats. Frequently the choice of next initiative and the time devoted to any initiative depends on the availability of grants to support the work.
Following this model of reform, educators can appear to be working to improve curriculum and instruction while avoiding implementing any new practices. This also allows educators to abandon any initiatives that force them to resolve any challenges to their existing practice.
Teachers, faculties, schools, and the entire education system will be prepared for digital generations only when educators accept the challenge of reinventing (and continuing to reinvent) their practice. The reinvention also requires that political leaders recognize the nature of learning. Educational paradigms that focus on instruction and measure achievement with standardized tests are naïve and ignore the facts of human nature and the skills necessary for full participation in the emerging culture.
If you're hearing a lot about the fediverse these days, you should know: Mastodon is not the whole fediverse and the fediverse is not simply a Twitter replacement. The fediverse is an entire ecosystem, built on something called ActivityPub. Learn more: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/11/leaving-twitters-walled-garden
https://twitter.com/naomicfisher/status/1596830703957573632?s=12&t=1fyXG3aJe6HKRyo3O-Om6Q
Even if you have given up on Twitter, go back and read this thread.
Classrooms with seats in rows.
This elicits vastly different responses from teachers.
#edutooter #education
When I was an undergraduate student doing botany research, we realized our measurements were proxies for something else. They were not reified in our minds. One thing that drive me out of k-12 teaching in the US, was the fact that test scores had become reified. #edutooter #edutoot #education
I'm with Niels Bohr when it comes to #logic:
"No, no, you're not thinking; you're just being logical.”
It never ceases to amaze me to observe two or more people discussing “learning” and seeing they each have vastly different concepts of it but no one realizes it, yet they argue on. #EduTooter #education #teaching #learning
Do web services improve the efficiency and effectiveness of instruction and school operation?
- Provide email and similar messaging services
- Maintain an active and up-to-date web and social media presence
- Ensure classroom information, resources, and interaction is available on the web
- Have a library with appropriate digital materials
- Ensure and improve accessibility and mobile compatibility of web services
- Use the web to facilitate purchasing, permissions, and similar administrative tasks
Two questions to ask about #school #IT #education #edutoot
Are there sufficient computing devices available in the school?
- Enough devices so teachers’ decisions are not limited
- Enough capacity that students can create products teachers deem appropriate
- Methods to easily share limited resources
Is the school’s information technology network reliable, robust, and secure?
- Allows all devices to connect without delay
- Has no latency
- Protects data and systems from threats
As they collaborate to make decisions about what technology to install and how to manage it, school and technology leaders must share understanding of three ideas.
First, the systems must be sufficiently secure to remain functional and reliable, but open enough to allow for the functions educators deem necessary.
Second, to accomplish secure yet flexible systems, educators and technicians must engage in an on-going process to improve technology systems.
Third, all stakeholders must recognize the complex nature of the enterprise networks in schools.
Director of Teaching and Learning Innovation at a community college in New England
Retired k-12 science/ math/ technology teacher/ technology integration specialist/ coordinator